Alan Miklofsky Consulting Website

CHANNEL STRATEGY: HOW NOT TO THROW INDEPENDENTS UNDER THE BUS

By Alan Miklofsky – December 2, 2025

If you want independent comfort retailers to bet their wall space and cash flow on your brand, there’s one non-negotiable: they have to believe you’re not going to undercut them the minute your DTC or a big-box account sniffs opportunity.

You can’t say “We love our independent partners” and then train customers to wait for a coupon on your website or a blowout at a national chain. Retailers are not stupid. They watch your behavior more closely than your marketing.

This is where channel strategy stops being theory and turns into whether you get written next season.

WHAT RETAILERS ARE SECRETLY ASKING

Every buyer in an independent store is asking three questions about you, even if they’re smiling:

· Will you sell the same product cheaper online?

· Will you give my customer a better deal somewhere else?

· If this brand takes off for me, will they protect my margin or quietly hollow it out?

Your channel strategy is how you answer those questions without a single slide deck.

MAP: PRINTED POLICY VS. REALITY

Lots of brands have MAP policies. Fewer brands actually enforce them. Independents know the difference.

If you want them on your side:

· Make MAP simple – not a 14-page legal riddle. Clear bands, clear rules, clear timing for promotions.

· Enforce it consistently – if you look the other way when a big online player breaks MAP, the message is loud: “The rules are for the small guys.” Word spreads.

· Align your own behavior – your website should not be playing coupon roulette while you ask retailers to hold the line on price. If you’re always running “20 percent off everything,” MAP is a joke.

A strong MAP program doesn’t mean no promotions. It means planned, limited, channel-respectful promotions that don’t train the customer to expect a permanent markdown.

DESIGNING A CHANNEL MIX THAT DOESN’T CANNIBALIZE ITSELF

You cannot be everywhere, do everything, and still expect independents to feel safe. You have to choose what each channel is for.

Think like this:

· Independents – fit, education, problem-solving, try-on, staff expertise, medical referrals, long-term loyalty.

· DTC – brand storytelling, special projects, long-tail styles, sizes and widths that are hard to stock broadly.

· Big box / nationals – volume players. Narrower assortments at sharper price points, with expectations of heavy promotions.

If every channel sells the same shoes, at the same time, with different discounts floating around, you’ve created chaos. Customers will figure out the cheapest path in about ten minutes.

Give each channel a defined role and then build your assortment and pricing to match that role.

CHANNEL-SPECIFIC PRODUCT THAT IS ACTUALLY MEANINGFUL

Channel-specific product is powerful when it protects relationships. It is annoying when it is fake differentiation that no one asked for.

Done well, channel-specific product looks like:

· Independents getting styles built for fit and problem-solving, with deeper size runs and widths, plus a few colors that are exclusive to their channel.

· DTC getting experimental styles, limited capsules, and long-tail sizes and colors that are hard for stores to stock but useful for brand loyalists.

· Big box getting simplified, price-focused ranges that do not step directly on the toes of what independents are trying to build.

Done badly, channel “exclusives” are just slightly recolored versions of the same style, dumped into every channel with different marketing language. Retailers see through that quickly.

If you promise independents product that is “theirs,” it needs to be more than one odd color and a different hangtag. It has to be something a customer would actually notice and choose.

PROMOTIONS THAT DON’T POISON THE WELL

Promotions are where channel strategy often explodes. One reckless DTC sale can undo months of careful positioning with independents.

To avoid poisoning the well:

· Plan promotions on a calendar and share it with your key independent accounts. No surprises.

· Keep true “fire sale” activity to your own closed channels (email lists, loyalty programs) and off the public stage where it can be screenshotted forever.

· Limit blanket percentage-off events on your entire site; focus on discontinueds, colors that are being retired, or styles that are not core to the independent channel.

· If you run a big public promotion, give independents tools to respond: temporary MAP adjustments, co-op support, or short-term allowances so they are not left looking like the expensive option.

The unspoken rule should be simple: you never use your own channels to make your best independent accounts look foolish for believing in your price structure.

DISTRIBUTION DECISIONS THAT SIGNAL RESPECT

Where you place your brand says as much as how you price it. Independents pay close attention to who else is on the roster.

They notice when:

· You quietly open a national chain in their market with overlapping assortments and sharper pricing.

· You flood marketplace platforms with the same SKUs they are trying to build at full price.

· You chase every door you can find, then talk about “partnership” out of the other side of your mouth.

Smart brands decide in advance which channels are strategic and which are opportunistic. Then they behave accordingly.

If independents are genuinely strategic for you, that should show up in who you say “no” to, not just in who you say “yes” to.

COMMUNICATION: TELL THEM BEFORE THEIR CUSTOMERS DO

Channel moves are not the problem. Surprise channel moves are the problem.

Partner-level communication looks like:

· Giving key independents a heads-up before major DTC campaigns or big-box launches go public.

· Explaining how a new channel or account fits into your overall strategy, in plain language, not spin.

· Being willing to hear pushback and adjust when something clearly jeopardizes long-term relationships.

Retailers know you will grow and evolve. What they are judging is whether you intend to grow with them or around them.

HOW INDEPENDENTS DECIDE IF THEY CAN TRUST YOUR CHANNEL STRATEGY

Over time, independents build a mental scoreboard on every brand. They are asking themselves:

· Do these folks protect my margin more often than they damage it?

· When they make a move, do I hear it from them first or from a screenshot my customer shows me on their phone?

· Are they using me as a showroom for their DTC and big-box business, or as a true long-term channel?

If the honest answers tilt the wrong way, you slowly get downgraded: fewer SKUs, smaller buys, no special placements, and eventually, no reorders.

If the answers tilt in your favor, something much better happens. Buyers start planning around you instead of around your competitors. They assume you are part of their future, not a temporary experiment.

That is what a coherent channel strategy delivers: independents who feel safe betting on you. Not because of a nice slide that says “We value our retail partners,” but because, season after season, your behavior proves it.